Friday, February 20, 2009

Carlton U admin clamps down on freedom of expression

We knew that this would be a possible outcome, that using the words "Israeli Apartheid" or images such as the poster below by Carlos Latuff most likely would rankle people in positions of power who have veto power or who will make your work more difficult to do, so to spare our group, The Human Rights Education Committee, the headaches and battles, we carefully crafted our words to address Palestinian Awareness. Sometimes one has to strategize one's methods according to place, time, and available energies and resources. Of course, if we were in Ottawa, Montreal or Toronto where there are 1000s of people to help in the fight for one's freedom of expression, then we too could take up other tactics. But we are in Thunder Bay, with limited resources and time to battle obstructions to thwart our message, which is simply to get information about Palestine out into public spaces. The students at Carlton University, however, have the Administration to battle, and are asking for support in their right of freedom of expression. See below.

The "offensive" Israeli Apartheid poster. Image by Carlos Latuff, a political cartoonist born in Brazil.

Dear Colleagues - please scroll to end of e-mail to see Actions requested.

Carleton University Administration violates free expression - bans and confiscates posters
Write to Carleton University president to demand the restoration of student rights
February 18, 2009

On February 8, Students Against Israeli Apartheid at Carleton University put up 100 posters for "Israeli Apartheid Week", a series of lectures and public events that will occur on campuses in over 40 cities around the world. On February 9, these posters were taken down at the request of Carleton's Equity Services, under the rationale that the posters "could be seen to incite others to infringe rights protected in the Ontario Human Rights code" and are "insensitive to the norms of civil discourse in a free and democratic society"

The poster was created by noted cartoonist Carlos Latuff and depicts a situation - a child being killed by aerial bombardment - that occurred over 430 times in Israel's latest attack on Gaza according to United Nations reports. We encourage everyone to view the poster: Since it depicts a situation that has a factual basis and its intention is clearly to invite people to a lecture series, the notion that it is an incitement or a violation to norms of civil discourse is preposterous.

This is part of a wider pattern of repression of academic freedom and rights to free expression, especially on Israel/Palestine, on Canadian campuses, including Carleton University. It is accompanied by double standards. When 56 Carleton professors asked President Roseanne Runte to condemn Israel's bombardment of the Islamic University of Gaza, the President refused. Neither the direct killing of hundreds of children nor the direct bombing of a campus are enough to elicit condemnation, but her administration has decided that a poster inviting people to discuss the conflict ought to be banned. Instead of being lauded by their university, students affirming the humanity of all peoples and the universality of international law have been threatened by Carleton University's Provost with expulsion.

The Carleton administration had already taken a biased political stand on the Israel-Palestine conflict, and is now violating free expression to prevent alternative views. Both the current and former Carleton Presidents have taken very clear positions on the Israel-Palestine conflict by condemning the academic boycott of Israel out of hand, offering no alternative to this justice-oriented civil-society initiative. Students and faculty at Carleton have requested that the administration hold a public debate on the issue, to allow the Carleton community to determine the most responsible course of action, yet have been repeatedly rebuffed.

Far from defending human rights, the Carleton administration is treating them with contempt. In a memo to students on February 12, the Provost wrote that "all reported incidents of racial or religious intolerance will be investigated vigorously and addressed regardless of the persons or groups involved." The administration should begin a vigorous investigation of its own behaviour, including its discrimination against students who seek an open debate on a political issue but are being silenced because they happen to disagree with the president's stand.

That Carleton's administration is using human rights grounds to violate free expression on its campus is a double insult. Internationally, the movement against Israeli apartheid has been endorsed by hundreds of universities, unions, religious groups and social justice organizations. This campaign is proudly anti-racist, and founded on the principles of opposition to all forms of racism, anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. It draws its inspiration from the global campaign to end South African apartheid and is led by many of the same individuals who were at the forefront of that earlier struggle. By contrast, the administration that banned the poster could not summon enough concern for human rights or the right to education to speak against the bombing of a Gazan university.

SAIA Carleton demands that the Carleton University administration:

1. Immediately lift the ban on the Israeli Apartheid Week poster and publicly apologize for the banning.

2. Explain, publicly and precisely, how the profound error of banning the poster was made and address how to prevent such violations from occurring in future.

3. Sponsor a full public debate-- ensuring generous access to the entire university community-- on Carleton's position on the proposed institutional boycott of Israeli academic institutions.

4. Appoint a university/community Commission to investigate the record of the University in relation to democratic discourse and equity around issues of Palestine solidarity.

This attempt to repress free expression will ultimately fail. The Carleton University administration should understand that debates on campuses on some of the most important human rights questions of our times cannot be silenced by administrative rulings.

We call on student organizations, social justice groups and concerned individuals around the world to support students at Carleton and the broader fight for freedom of expression.

Please take the following actions:

* Immediately email the Carleton University President, Roseanne Runte, at demanding that she immediately restore the Charter rights of Carleton students and send a copy of your message of support to Students Against Israeli Apartheid (SAIA Carleton) at

* Call or fax Carleton University President, Roseanne Runte, at 613 520-3801(phone) or 613 520-4474 (fax) demanding that she immediately restore the Charter rights of Carleton students.


velvel in decatur said...

and what if the jewish students has a noted artist draw a poster showing palestinians dancing around dismembered women or stoned women? would you call the university to remove the poster or would you call it freedom of expression?

Kreplach said...

Blatant propaganda should not be banned but debated and humiliated.
The Latuff poster is a clear naive summation of the Gaza conflict that in no way reflects reality. Gaza kids have Teddy bears? What would the Gaza Imans say? And why is a gunship firing a on a little kid? Are thety referring to civilian deaths during the Gaza war. Does the IDF have magical X ray vision misiles aimed at children? Give me a break!